Muddy's is located on the SW tip of the island and is a notable surf spot known for its solid waves. This area tends to pick up the most swell, especially when conditions align just right. It’s a popular spot for experienced surfers looking for some fun on the water, but it’s not always reliable, so keep your expectations in check.

The waves here are primarily lefts, breaking over live coral. Muddy's handles swell sizes starting from 2ft (about 0.6 meters) and can go much bigger when the conditions are right. The best time to hit the surf is in NE winds, especially during low to high tides. So, if you’re an expert surfer looking for a challenge, Muddy's can deliver, particularly when the southwest swell is rolling in.

Since this spot is a reef break, make sure you know what you’re doing out there. It’s not the most beginner-friendly place, but for those who have the skills, it can provide some solid barrels and fun sessions. Timing your visit with the right swell direction from the south or west will help you catch the best waves.